
GEOGRAPHY 5157
GIS For Economic Geography and Business Decisions
(Last
revised, January 04, 2005)
Department of Geography,
University of Florida
SpringTerm 2005 -- Section 4814X
Thursday periods 7, 8, 9(1:55 - 4:55)
Location: 3018 Turlington Hall |
Grant Ian Thrall, Professor
Office Hours:
Click here for information
Office: 3121 Turlington Hall
|
| URL: www.thrall.cjb.net |
tel: 1-352-392-4652
E-mail: thrall@geog.ufl.edu |
Return to Professor
Thrall's University of Florida WWW Page
Return To Top Of
Form
COURSE DESCRIPTION
This course examines the general methods of business geography,
including those of William Applebaum and extending through to the contemporary
GIS technology and data sets. Emphasis is on the use of GIS and geographic
analysis in business decisions.
Geographic Information Systems (GIS) is the technology
for the creation, modification, display and analysis of spatial information.
To be knowledgeable of GIS one must be familiar with geographic analysis
and reasoning, knowledgeable of geographic data bases, and familiar with
computer software and hardware technology, and familiar with the geography
technology industry. This course builds upon Geo 3171, Foundations of GIS,
by examining each of these topics as they relate to how professional human
economic geographers practice GIS in the business community.
Advances in geographic information systems (GIS) technology
has increased the value and stature of the human economic geographer in
the business community. This course focuses upon the practice, technology
and reasoning of human economic geography as applied in the business community
today.
Return To Top Of
Form
PREREQUISITES
Students must have completed Geo 3171 and Foundations of GIS, or their
university level equivalent. Undergraduate students must also have senior
level standing, or permission of the instructor. Students must have completed
Urban Geography 3602 or 4620.
Students are required to either be familiar with ArcView GIS software,
and skilled in the use of a microcomputer, or have permission of the instructor.
Students are required to have access to their own microcomputer capable
of running ArcView, as well as storing about 20 MB of data.
Return To Top Of
Form
Course Outline
Required Reading: Grant Thrall, 2002. Business Geography And New
Real Estate Market Analysis, Oxford University Press: Oxford and NY.
The following topics proceed through Thrall (2002), chapter by chapter.
Additional readings follow, most of which are on-line to registered students
in this course.
- Preface
- Part I: Overview, Theory, Methods
- Chapter 1: Introduction To Business Geography And Real Estate Market
Analysis
- Chapter 2: Understanding Real Estate Markets And Submarkets
- Chapter 3: Unifying Urban Land Value And Land Use Theory
- Chapter 4: Conducting Real Estate Market Analysis
- Part II: Applications To Real Estate Product Types
- Chapter 5: Housing And Communities
- Chapter 6: Office And Industrial Market Analysis
- Chapter 7: Retail Market Analysis
- Chapter 8: Hotel And Motel Market Analysis: The Hospitality Industry
- Chapter 9: Mixed Use
- Chapter 10: Getting Started
Return To Top Of
Form
RECOMMENDED
ADDITIONAL BACKGROUND READINGS
Students are recommended to have mastered the following. Some possible
background readings are provided for each topic:
- Central Place Theory
Les King, 1984. Central Place Theory,
Beverly Hills: Sage Publications
- Gravity and Spatial Interaction Models
Kingsley Haynes and A. Stewart Fotheringham,
1984. Gravity and Spatial Interaction Models, Beverly Hills: Sage
Publications
- Industrial Location
Michael Webber, 1984. Industrial Location,
Beverly Hills: Sage Publications.
- Spatial Diffusion
Richard Morrill, Gary Gaile, Grant Thrall,
1987. Spatial Diffusion. Beverly Hills: Sage Publications
- Urban Land Use and spatial development patterns
Grant Thrall, 1988. Land Use and Urban
Form. London: Routledge/Methuen Ltd.
Students should become familiar with the two leading
trade publications of the industry: GeoInfo
Systems and Business
Geographics.
Return To Top Of
Form
LINKS
TO GIS SOFTWARE COMMONLY USED IN BUSINESS GEOGRAPHY
Return To
Top Of Form
TEXTBOOK
Grant Thrall, 2001. Business Geography And New Real Estate Market
Analysis, Oxford University Press: Oxford and NY. (a photocopy version
will be available pending printing by Oxford).
Return To Top Of
Form
ADDITIONAL
READINGS BY TOPIC
I.
Introduction And Motivation
GIS
and Business Geography
This introduction to the course answers how GIS can conceptually
be applied to business decisions, what are the issues and obstacles. Business
geography is inherently applied. Equal to the issue of rigor in business
geography are the concepts of relevance and cost effectiveness. Analysis
and the strategic management performing the analysis, will ultimately be
evaluated on the basis of the value added to to the business decision,
and the cost of that value added.
- 1997 - "How GIS Can Put Urban
Economic Analysis on the Map," Journal of Housing Economics.
Vol. 6, No. 4, December 1997, pp. 368-386. (John M. Clapp, Mauricio Rodriguez,
Grant Thrall)
- 1997 - "GIS and Business Geography:
A Retrospective." Geo Info Systems, volume 7, number 6, June,
pages 46-52. (Grant Thrall)
- 1992 - "Improving Real Estate
Market Research," Real Estate Issues, vol. 17, nu. 1, Spring/Summer
1992; pp. 1-7. (Robert Pittman and Grant Thrall).
- 1997
- "Business Geography, Where Is It Going?" Geo Info Systems,
volume 7, number 9, September 1997. Pages 46 - 48. (Grant Ian Thrall).
- "Molly
Trudeau's Interview with Grant Thrall" Geo Info Systems "Showcase,"
August, vol 6 no 8, 1996. (Grant Ian Thrall and Molly Trudeau).
GIS Reasoning
This section deals with the conceptual organization
of the myriad of facts and information into a structure that can be evaluated
and reasoned with using geographic technology.
- 1997 - "Real Estate Problem Solving
and Geographic Information Systems: A Stage Model of Reasoning." Journal
of Real Estate Literature, vol. 5, number 2, July, 177-201. (Grant
Thrall and Larry Wofford)
- 1995
- "Stages of GIS Reasoning" Geo Info Systems February
1995, vol 5 no 2, pp 46-51. (Grant Ian Thrall)
- Susan
Cutter, 2001, Taking some of the ivory out of the ivory tower" President's
Column, AAG Newsletter, March 2001.
Return To Top Of
Form
II.
Housekeeping, Data, Spatial Data Functions, Mapmaking
It can be said that GIS is 90% data. In business
geography, issues of data are paramount. Business geography differs from
say planning geography and other applied divisions of geography in that
in business geography it is seldom economically feasible to build unique
databases strictly for the purpose of geographic analysis. Business geographers
purchase data that, through high volume distribution, becomes inexpensive
for the individual consumer. Data that is normally maintained by the business
can be made to be geographically enabled through various batch mode geocoding
procedures.
Data - Getting Started
- 1993 -
"Commercial Data for the Business GIS (Part One)," Geo Info
Systems, vol. 3, nu. 7, pp. 63-68 (Grant Thrall and Dr. Susan Elshaw
Thrall).
- 1993 - "Business
GIS Data, Part Two: Highend Tiger/Line," Geo Info Systems,
vol. 3, nu. 9, 66-70. (Grant Thrall and Dr. Susan Elshaw Thrall).
- 1994 - "Business
GIS Data, Part Three: ZIP Plus 4 Geocoding," Geo Info Systems,
vol. 4, nu. 1, January, 57-60. (Grant Thrall and Dr. Susan Elshaw Thrall).
- 1994 - "Business
GIS Data, Part Four: Attribute Data," Geo Info Systems, Vol
4, No 3, March 1994; 62-70 (Grant Thrall).
- 1994 - "Business GIS Data, Part Five: Linking
Attribute Data To Map Objects," Geo Info Systems, vol 4, no 5, May
1994; 49 - 54. (Grant Thrall and Susan Elshaw Thrall).
- 1995 - "Business
GIS Data Part 6: When Is ZIP+2 Good Enough," Geo Info Systems,
vol 5, nu 11, November 1995; 40-43. (G. Thrall, J del Valle, S. Thrall)
Data - Business Applications
Software functionality issues
- 1993 - "Functional
Requirements of a Geographic Information System for Performing Real Estate
Research and Analysis," Journal of Real Estate Literature,
vol 1, nu 1, January, pp. 49-61. (Grant Thrall & A Marks)
- 1994 - Criteria
and Definitions for the Evaluation of Geographic Information System Software
for Real Estate Analysis," Journal of Real Estate Literature,
vol 2, nu. 2, 227-241. (A. Marks, C. Stanley and G. Thrall).
- 1992 - "Using
the JOIN Function to Compare Census Tract Populations Between Census Years,"
Geo Info Systems, vol. 2, nu. 5, May 1992; pp. 78-81. (Grant Thrall)
Return To Top Of
Form
Most of GIS is descriptive. Because few business
managers have backgrounds in geographic analysis and geographic reasoning,
their first introduction to output of GIS will be in the form of descriptive
reports of data that they are already familiar. Spatial data visualization
is important because it comes early in the development cycle of a business
GIS and must be relied upon to generate additional and continuing funding.
- 1993 - "Using
a GIS to Rate the Quality of Property Tax Appraisal," Geo Info
Systems, vol 3, nu 3, pp. 56-62. (Grant Thrall)
- 1993 "Using
GIS to Analyze and Visualize Spatial Data", Geo Info Systems.
vol 3, nu 5, pp. 59-65. (Grant Thrall M Ruiz, C Sidman, S Thrall)
- 1995
- "Location Quotient: Descriptive Geography for the Community Reinvestment
Act" Geo Info Systems, volume 5, Number 6, June 1995; pages
18-22. Grant Ian Thrall, Judy Fandrich, and Susan Elshaw-Thrall)
Return To Top Of
Form
Descriptive presentations should naturally evolve
into searches for explanation for the spatial pattern. Ideally, the general
theory should proceed the descriptive GIS. So, for example, Grant Thrall's
1987 book Land Use and Urban Form, referenced above as background
reading, provides anticipation of how cities evolve spatially. The GIS
analysis then can be used to link the general theory to description and
thereby be used for explanation.
With explanation, predictive models have their foundation
in general theory, and thereby become linked to the larger body of understanding.
Business decisions normally require judgment for an action today whose
consequences will be felt into the future. Therefore, knowledge of the
future consequences of actions today, and knowledge of the geographic landscape
are imperative for good business decisions.
- 1998 - "Common
Geographic Errors of Real Estate Analysis." Journal of Real Estate
Literature, vol. 6, number 1, 1998. (Grant Thrall)
- 1993
- "The Cascade GIS Diffusion Model for Measuring Housing Absorption
by Small Area with a Case Study of St. Lucie County, Florida," Journal
of Real Estate Research, vol. 8, Nu. 3, Summer 1993; pp. 401-420. (Grant
Thrall and C Sidman, S Thrall, T Fik.)
Return To Top Of
Form
The degree to which judgment is improved by geographic
analysis and geographic technology places limits on how much business is
willing to invest in the creation and maintenance of their GIS. GIS staff
also cannot ignore the process by which their GIS output contributes to
decision making.
- 1991 - "Using
The Delphi Method for GIS Criteria" Geo Info Systems, vol.
1 no 1, pp 46-52. (Grant Thrall and J. William McCartney)
- 1988. "Greenspace
acquisition and ranking program (GARP): a computer assisted decision strategy."
Computers, Environment, and Urban Systems, Vol. 12, 161- 184. (Grant
Thrall, Bert Swanson, Dominic Nozzi).
- 1992 - "Siting Hospitals To Provide
Cost-Effective Health Care," Geo Info Systems, vol 2, nu 8,
September, pp. 58-66. (Allen P. Marks, Grant Ian Thrall and Michael Arno)
- 1997 - "The Development of a
Senior Housing Expert Decision System - A Theoretical Model & Systems
Framework," National Investment Conference Review (Research, Case
Studies and Strategies for Investing in the Senior Living and Long Term
Care Industries), volume 5, pp. 3-16 (Steven Laposa, Grant Thrall, David
Watkins).
- 2000 - "The
Future of GIS in Public Health Management and Practice," Journal
of Public Health Care And Management, Centers For Disease Control And
Prevention, June 1999.
- 1990 - "A
Computer Assisted Decision Strategy For Evaluating New Satellite Hub Sites
For a Local Utility Provider" (Grant Thrall with Susan Elshaw); Computers,
Environment, and Urban Systems. Vol. 14, 37-48.
- 1991 - "Reducing
Investor Risk: A GIS Design For Real Estate Analysis," Geo Info
Systems, vol. 1, nu. 10, Nov/Dec. (Grant Thrall and Susan Elshaw-Thrall).
- 1991 - "Real Estate Acquisition
Decisions With GIS: Ranking Property For Purchase," Proceedings of
the Annual GIS/LIS Conference, October, Atlanta GA. ((Grant Thrall and
J. William McCartney).
- 1996 - "Measuring the Development
Potential of an Historic Downtown," Geo Info Systems, 6 (4
April) 44-49 (Grant Thrall and Juan del Valle, Paul Amos and Ken McGurn.)
- 1991 - "Using Geographic Information
Systems In Economic Development," Economic Development Review, vol.
9, nu. 4, Fall; pp 14-21. (Robert Pittman and Grant Thrall).
Return To Top Of
Form
VII.
Management, Implementation And Monitoring
After a decision has been made, the results of the
decision must be monitored to notify the analyst if additional attention,
and perhaps reevaluation, should be done. Not only should the consequences
of the decisions be monitored, but also the process and procedure of how
the decision is made must continually be reexamined with respect to changing
technologies, and improved forms of analysis.
- 1994 - "A History of Implementing
an Urban GIS, Part One: Design, Tribulations, and Failure," Geo
Info Systems, July, p. 50 - 58. (Grant Thrall and Marilyn Ruiz)
- 1994 - "A History of Implementing
an Urban GIS, Part Two: Two Solutions Toward a Working GIS," Geo
Info Systems, vol 4, nu 10, October, p. 46 - . (Grant Thrall and Marilyn
Ruiz and Bob Bates)
Return
To Top Of Form
VIII.
The Technology For Business
It has been said that GIS is data, software, hardware,
analysis, and people to put it all together. To that list should be added
"knowledge of the GIS industry." Business geographers make recommendations
on which technology (data, software, hardware) to purchase. Without knowledge
of the industry, appropriate analysis might not be produced, and analysis
performed might not be completed in the most cost effective manner.
- Thrall, Grant Ian. 1998b. "CACI
Coder/plus version 1, Review." Geo Info Systems, 8 (6) 43-46.
- Thrall, Grant Ian. 1998c. "CACI
Site Reporter with Scan/US, Review." Geo Info Systems, 8 (6) 46-49.
- 1996 - "Modular Component Programming:
The Foundations of GIS Applications," Geo Info Systems, vol
6, nu 2, February; 45-46. (Grant Thrall)
- 1995 - "New Generation of Mass-Market
GIS Software: A Commentary," Geo Info Systems, vol 5, nu 9,
September 1995; pp 58-60. (Grant Thrall)
- 1995 - "Review of Four GUI Based
GIS Software Products," Geo Info Systems, vol 5, nu 9, September
1995; pp 60-65. (Grant Thrall and Juan del Valle and Susan Elshaw Thrall).
- 1996 - "Surfer: review of three
dimensional surface modeling software," Journal of Real Estate Literature,
vol 4, nu 1, January; pp. 73-75. (Grant Thrall)
- 1997 - "The Web-ulous World of
GIS." Geo Info Systems, November, March, vol. 7, no. 3: p.
52-55 (Grant Thrall)
Return To Top Of
Form
In the below series of articles, the
authors provide a detailed outline of how a retail business can use GIS
to improve its management decisions. In the authors' conceptualization,
retail location is approached from the viewpoint that the decision is made
top-down:
Marketing And Business Geography Background
Strategic Management - Red Lobster Example
- which regions should be entered, in
which order, and when
- where within the regions should trade
zones be established
- where within the trade zones should
the retail facility be built
- monitor the decision
- 1997 - "Retail
Location Analysis With GIS: Seven Strategic Steps." Geo Info Systems,
vol. 7, number 10, 1997; pp. 42-45. (Grant Thrall, Juan del Valle and
Gordon Hinzmann)
- 1998 - "Applying the Seven-Step
Site Selection Methodology to Red Lobster Restaurants: Steps One and Two."
Geo Info Systems, vol. 8, number 2, 1998; pp. 40-43. (Grant Thrall,
Juan del Valle and Gordon Hinzmann)
- 1998 - "Retail
Location Analysis, Step Three: Assessing Relative Performance." Geo
Info Systems, vol. 8, number 4; pp. 38-44. (Grant Thrall, Juan del
Valle and Gordon Hinzmann)
- 1998 - "Retail Location Analysis,
Step Four: Identify Situation Targets." Geo Info Systems, vol.
8, number 6, 1998; pp. 38-43. (Grant Thrall, Juan del Valle and Gordon
Hinzmann)
- 1998 - "Retail
Location Analysis, Step Five: Assess Market Penetration," Geo Info
Systems, vol. 8, number 9, 1998; pp. 46-50. (Grant Thrall, Juan del
Valle and Gordon Hinzmann)
- 1998 - "Retail
Location Analysis, Step Six: Identify Markets For Expansion," Geo
Info Systems; 8(11). (Grant Thrall, Juan del Valle and Gordon Hinzmann)
- 1998 - "Retail Location Analysis,
Step Seven: Judgment, Implementation, Monitoring," Geo Info Systems;
vol. 8, number 11, (Grant Thrall).
Office Market Absoprtion Series
- 1999 - "Urban Office Market
Evaluation With GIS, Part 1: Background and Setting." Geo Info
Systems, vol. 9, number 4; 32-36. (Grant Thrall and Paul Amos)
- 1999 - "Urban Office Market
Evaluation With GIS, Part 2: The Decision To Build." Geo Info Systems,
vol. 9, number 6; 40-46. (Grant Thrall and Paul Amos)
- 1999 - "Urban Office Market
Evaluation With GIS, Part 3: The Decision To Locate." Geo Info
Systems, vol. 9, number 9; 39-45. (Grant Thrall and Paul Amos)
- 1999 - "Urban Office Market
Evaluation With GIS, Part 4: The Decision To Build." Geo Info Systems,
vol. 9, number 11; 44-49. (Grant Thrall and Paul Amos)
Retail Market Analysis
Draft of Chapter 7 in Grant Thrall, 2000. Real
Estate Market Analysis, Urban Land Institute: Washington D.C.
Other
Return To Top Of
Form
Additional Readings
- Housing - owner occupied
- Housing - rental
- Office
- Industrial
- Retail
- Hotel
- Mixed Use
Lists
Housing - owner occupied
Housing - rental
Office
- Anari M A, Hunt H D, 2002, "Natural vacancy rates in major Texas
office market" Monograph, Real Estate Center, Texas A&M University,
Texas
- Barras R, 1987, "Technical change and urban development cycle"
Urban Studies, 24(1) 5-30.
- Berry B, 1993, "The multinodal metopolis" Geographical Analysis
15(1) 1- 82
- Brennan T P, Cannaday R E, Colwell P F, 1984, "Office rent in
Chicago CBD" AREUEA Journal 12(3) 243-260
- Chesterton/EGi, 1997, London Office Database (Estate Gazette Interactive,
London)
- Clapp J H, 1993, "Dynamics of office markets: empirical findings
and research issues" AREUEA Journal Monograph: Series No. 1, The Urban
Institute Press, Washington DC
- Clapp, J H, Pollakowski O, Lynford L K, 1992, "Intrametropolitan
location and office market dynamics" AREUEA Journal 20(2) 229-258
- Daniels P W, 1993, Service Industries in the World Economy (Blackwell
Publishers, Oxford, UK)
- DiPasquale D, Wheaton W C, 1992, "The markets for real estate
asset and space: a conceptual framework" AREUEA Journal 20(2) 181-198
- DiPasquale D, Wheaton W C, 1995, The Economics of Real Estate Markets
(Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliff, NJ)
- Hekman J, 1985, "Rental price adjustment investment in the office
market" AREUEA Journal 13(1) 2-47
- Hendershott P H, 2000, "Property asset bubbles: evidence from
the Syndey office market" AREUEA Journal 20(1) 67-81
- Hendershott P H, Lizieri C .M, Matysiak G A, 1999, "The workings
of the London office market" Real Estate Economics 27(2) 365-387
- Kelly H D, 1983, "Forecasting office space demand in urban areas"
Real Estate Review 13 87-95
- Kling J L, McCue T E, 1987, "Office building investment and the
macroeconomy: empirical evidence 1973-1985" AREUEA Journal 15(3) 234-255
- Kooijman D, 2000, "The office building: between globalization
and local identity" Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design
27(6) 827-842
- McDonald J F, 2002, "A survey of econometric models of office
markets" Journal of Real Estate Literature 10(2) 223-242
- Noyelle T, Stanback T .M, 1984, The Economic Transformation of American
Cities (Rowman & Allenheld, Totawa, NJ)
- Rodriguez M, Sirmans, C F, Marks A P, 1995, "Using geographic
information systems to improve real estate analysis" Journal of Real
Estate Research 10(2) 163-174
- Rosen K T, 1984, " Toward a model of the office building model"
AREUEA Journal 12(3) 261-269
- Shilling J D, Sirmans, C F, Corgel J B, 1987, "Price adjustment
process for rental office space" Journal of Urban Economics 22(1)
90-100
- Shilton L, 1994, "The eight myths of office demand forecasting"
Real Estate Finance Journal Winter 67-72
- Sivitanides P S, 1997, "The rent adjustment process and the structural
vacancy rate in the commercial real estate market" Journal of Real
Estate Research 13(2) 195-209
- Weaver W C, 1983, "Forecasting office space demand with conjoint
measurement techniques" Appraisal Journal July 389-398
- Wheaton W C, 1987, "The cyclical behavior of the national office
market" AREUEA Journal 15(4) 281-299
- Wheaton W C, Torto R G, 1988, "Vacancy rates and the future of
office rents" AREUEA Journal 16(4) 430-436
- Wheaton W C, Torto R G, Evans P, 1997, "The cyclical behavior
of the Greater London office market" Journal of Real Estate Finance
and Economics 15(1) 77-92
Industrial
Retail
Hotel
Mixed Use
GRADING
- 30% term paper-- A term paper will be presented
in Microsoft Powerpoint as though given to a client.
- 30% midterm exam --.
- 10% discussion participation and preparation
before class
- 30% final exam -- exam
#2, Spring 2000. ** exam #2 Spring 2001
Return To Top Of
Form
(c) 1999 - 2002. Grant Ian Thrall, Gainesville FL and Vail CO. All rights
reserved.