POS 4291
Dr. Wald
Spring 2010
Paper #1
Due on Thursday, February 4th
Your assignment is to study a religious organization from a
political
perspective. You are to select a religious group/congregation (a
specific church, synagogue,
mosque, etc.) and study it by means of both personal observation and
the
Internet. In selecting a group for study, you must be able to make a
firsthand
visit during worship services. During the visit, you should observe the
group and
talk to the members. In the second data collection strategy, you will
"visit"
the web page of the church or its central denomination and examine the
contents and links.
What to Look For: Based on your observations, discuss the
role
of politics in the religious group you have visited. In visiting the
actual
church, you can watch, talk to people and read literature. Using the
web,
you will have to examine the contents closely and follow any links to
other
web sites. Because "politics" can be subtle as well as overt, it is
important
to look for a variety of clues. Look for
- evidence of political activities such as voter registration,
recruitment
for political campaigns, and political slogans on bumper stickers,
publications,
and links
- the nature of appeals to intellect and emotion, a this-worldly
vs.
other-worldly
orientation, ritual, participation of members, etc.
- leadership activity and styles, political advocacy, civic
involvement,
etc.
- group activities involving society and community, civic
activities,
policy
positions, endorsement of candidates or movements
- role of women, governing structures
There is a very good guide to congregational observation available here.
Keep in mind that the guide is not designed for political science but
has general guidance about visiting religious organizations and some
useful suggestions about what to examine.
Contents: The paper should describe the church or organization,
assess any political messages that members are likely to encounter,
suggest
the social and political concerns of the group, and discuss the
leadership's
role and attitudes toward social and political questions. The best
papers, which are typically based on more than one visit and also
consult relevant scholarly materials,
usually
- provide a summary of the history and evolution of the religious
organization
and its core doctrines. Such papers often demonstrate how the
organization's
history and development affected its political perspectives.
- emphasize the political positions that are taken by the
organization
(to
the degree they are discernible) and how they are linked to the
organization's
religious vision. This often includes comments about the political
structure of the organization itself and discussion of the role of
women
in the church.
- exploit the available sources thoroughly. This means, for
example, that
students should cover the Web pages thoroughly (rather than simply
listing
it by topic) and follow the links. Students should report thoroughly on
what they saw and what they found out in their conversations. Multiple
visits are better than a single visit.
- utilize as many sources as possible. In particular, when there is
something
unique or distinctive about the tradition under study, the best papers
will consult additional information (books, newspaper articles, etc.)
to
explore further.
- follow accepted rules of good writing - proper grammar, correct
spelling,
complete sentences rather than fragments, appropriate capitalization of
words, etc.
- provide full information on citations and references, including
the
source
of quotations, controversial comments, etc. Web pages should also be
cited
properly and you can find a guide to doing that below.
Where to Start: The most comprehensive list of local churches is
found at Gainesville
Religious Organizations. Most local churches post a link to their
central
denomination or, if nondenominational, to some kind of national
organization.)
If you can't find it there, you should examine the Yahoo
index for religious groups or the Hartford
Seminary list of official denominational links. Far less
comprehensive and curiously unwilling to
acknowledge
Roman Catholicism or Judaism, the Denominations
Directory is nonetheless useful for some of the smaller and more
particularistic
denominations.
Some Guidelines and Rules:
- The paper is due in class on Thursday, February 4th.
You
may
also hand it in the Political Science office (234 Anderson Hall) before
the due date. Do not email it to me (although you may
email
early drafts if you would like comments.) Late papers are dropped one
grade
for each day they are late.
- You are not restricted to the Gainesville area for this
assignment. However,
I want you to stay away from campus for this assignment. Except for
religious
groups with main headquarters across from campus (the Mennonites) and
St.
Augustine (which serves the entire city), you are to go elsewhere for
your
case study.
- You will write a better paper if you cover a religious
tradition
other
than your own. That's advice rather than a rule. I've never received a
good paper on the Hare Krishnas so I would advise you to avoid them as
well.
- Students may form teams to visit churches but should still
write
individual
papers.
- All sources must be properly documented in a list of
references.
I prefer
what is known as the Harvard
or Chicago style with brief references in the body of the text and
a full
references
at the end of the paper. Anything cited on the Web must present
sufficient
information so that I can look it up. This requires providing the
author's
name, (if known); the full title of the work in italics; and the date
of
the document or last revision (if available). Next, list the protocol
(e.g.,
"http") and the full URL, followed by the date of access in
parentheses.
What to Avoid: Students sometimes treat web sites as if they
were
literally and figuratively true. For example, a church might describe
itself
in flowery language as "a community of Bible believers who practice the
Christianity of the New Testament." That is undoubtedly how the church
sees itself but it is an idealized vision that is based on
self-promotion.
As social analysts, you need to look beyond such descriptions and
approach
your case study with some degree of psychological distance. You could
say,
for example, that "the Church of True Believers defines itself as a
community
of Bible Believers . . " and then go on to describe it (if
appropriate)
as a "church affiliated with World-Wide Gospel Ministries, a
Dallas-based
organization that practices evangelical Protestantism with a strong
emphasis
on charismatic practice."
What to Hand In: Submit a hard copy printed with dark ink
and leave a generous left-hand margin for my comments. Do not bind this
with anything more elaborate than a staple. The paper should be
long
enough
to cover all the suggested contents. So to give you a completely
arbitrary
guideline, the paper should run between 5 and 10 pages.
| Despite the forbidding tone
of this
page, please feel free to contact me for advice. I realize this
assignment
might scare you and I'll be happy to give you advice on locating a
suitable
case study or other matters. |